Friday, 15 May 2020

BG7TBL FA-2 Frequency Counter Review

I’ve recently been playing around with creating my own GPSDO based upon an Arduino and Si5351a synthesiser and needed away to check the accuracy and all had to hand was a rather old Racal 9001 6 digit counter which wasn’t cutting the mustard.

A friend of mine recommended a BG7TBL FA-2 with a precision of 11 digits/second at 10MHz which can be bought from eBay for around £100 pounds including postage which is a lot cheaper than buying an older Racal 1998 10 digit counter which go for silly money.

For your £100 you get the following:

  1. Two channels one for measuring between 1Hz - 200MHz and the other between 200MHz and 6GHz.
  2. A sensitivity between 20dBm to -20dBm.
  3. 0.1, 1 and 10 second gate times.
  4. A frequency resolution at 10MHz of 0.001Hz with a 0.1/s gate, 0.0001Hz with a  1/s gate and 0.00001Hz with a 10/s gate.
  5. Switchable input impedance on CH1 between 50 and 1M ohms.
  6. 150kHz switchable LPF on CH1.
  7. 10MHz internal OCXO frequency standard with 0.5Hz/yr ageing.
  8. RF power meter able to measure between 20dBm to -50dBm.
  9. 10MHz frequency standard at 4dBm.
  10. 10MHz external frequency standard.
  11. USB serial interface.
  12. 12 Vdc PSU.



In the above picture of the front panel you can see its very simplistic consisting of three push and the two channel sockets.  

The mode button lets you switch between channels and whether or not to display averaging.  Gate allows to you to select one of the three gate options.  RST allows you to reset the averaging when displayed.

Some buttons operate in tandem with another to select additional options such as RST+GATE to turn the LPF on and off, RST+MODE switch between input impedances on CH1.

The rear panel has the 10MHz reference input and outputs, USB interface, DC power socket an on / off switch and access to an internal trimmer to adjust the internal OCXO.



To test the unit I used a LeoBodnar single output GPSDO locked to six satellites with a SNR greater than 40dB and set to 10MHz at -3dBm.

The Bodnar has a stated accuracy of 1ppb (parts per billion).  At 10MHz a we should should see a deviation of +/- 0.01Hz.

I wrote a piece of Python code to log the data from the USB serial interface and saved the data to CSV which I then processed again using Python and the matplotlib graphing library you can grab the code from https://github.com/M0WGF/RadioOddsAndSods

Both the FA-2 and GPSDO were kept at a fairly constant temperature of 18 degrees C for three hours before the test began.

On the FA-2 channel one was selected with the input set an impedance of 50 ohms, the LPF switched off and a 1/s gate time.

With the GPSDO connected and locked I switched the FA-2 on and started logging and to be honest went off for a cuppa thinking it would take awhile to stabilise and as you can see from the following chart that wasn’t at all the case.

You can see in the first five minutes there’s a rapid decrease before dipping below and returning to 10MHz as the OCXO heats up.  The first data point being taken at 16:37.



Below we zoom in just before the frequency dip.



As you can see the measured frequency at this scale is near as dammit spot on within thirteen minutes of switching the unit.

Next lets zoom in further and see how the stability looks in much finer detail.



As you can see the readings from the FA-2 are well within the +/- 0.01Hz measurement we were expecting from the Bodnar GPSDO.  

I would have liked to be able to check the accuracy in the GHz range but sadly I don’t possess an accurate signal source at those frequencies.

All in all I think for £100 unit from eBay it’s performance is excellent so if you’re in need of a cheap frequency counter the FA-2 seems to be a bit of a bargain.


5 comments:

  1. What do you have to download to get the graph onto the screen?

    ReplyDelete
  2. What do you have to download to get the graph onto the screen?

    ReplyDelete
  3. The device just outputs text from the rear port. The charts were made using Python and Matplotlib.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice review, thanks for sharing. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. use Timelab software to collect and graph (as you have done) with amazing analysis capabilities. As I am not a software kinda guy this was the easiest for me. I use the Leo Bodnar GPSDO, with the long term GPS accuracy, to reference my FA-3 counter which has the short term noise performance OCXO, to get combination results. then use the 10mhz output to lock the rest of the equipment. Spec An, Sig gen and all seems to work famously giving stability and accuracy unheard of a few years ago for such a modest cost. Still marvel at modern equipment and options available.

    ReplyDelete